One of my all-time favorite books by one of my all-time favorite authors, Sheri S. Tepper, is Gate to Women’s Country.I’ve read the book at least 3 times, but it’s been a while, and have just read about it in Wikipedia and in The Big A. I can tell it is time to re-read it because the thing I remember the most, and loved the most, is the way they fought wars. Projectiles were not allowed. Warriors had to be able to look to look their opponent in the eyes as they either prepared to kill or be killed. No atlatls, no spears, no bows and arrows, no darts, no projectiles. Period.
If you gotta fight a war, do it with dignity, with respect. No missiles, no bombs, no planes, no drones. Look your intended victim in the eyes and know whose life you’re taking. Or who is taking yours.
Why am I asking this question now, after her 1988 book has been out and is still selling? Because of Keith Olbermann’s podcast on Monday 12 Jan 26. The gun part starts at 15:18. There is research out there that shows that firing in indoor situations, and firing military weapons outdoors or indoors, leaves the shooters suffering concussion-like symptoms from the repeat blast exposure.
The New York Times has an article Target Shooting Could Be Causing Brain Injuries. We Measured the Danger. By Thomas Gibbons-Neff, Dave Philipps, and Jeremy White. Cinematography by Zach Caldwell and Jonah Markowitz. A friend kindly sent me the article, to which I am paywalled from, so I could read it. Well worth reading, however you can do it.
According to the US military findings, evidence shows “that firing some military weapons can damage brain clls, and repeate 4xposure may cause permanent injuries. But there is next to no public information about the strength of the blast waves delivered by civilian firearms, or the potential hazard.” [emphasis mine] (From NYT article)
To me, the most fascinating graphic of all three articles is in the one, about 2/3-3/4 of the way down the NYT one, where the guy is firing with a heavy metal curtain behind him to visibly show the shock waves as they pass over and through the shooter. How they twist, etc. Scary. Honest. Trust me.
NPR’s article, Blasts from military weapons may injure the brain yhrough its blood vessels has different information, including the quote below.
“A blast isn’t just like a blow to the head, when it comes to brain injury.
“A head impact tends to injure structures near the surface. A blast wave keeps going.
“The result can be impaired blood flow to an area like the brain stem, which controls breathing, heart rate, and blood pressure.”
The American Brain Foundation’s article, The Hidden Impact: How Military Activity Affects Brain Healtharticle opens with: “Military activity, specifically exposure to blasts in training and combat, can have a significant impact on brain health. Ongoing research is uncovering how repeated exposure to blast waves can cause brain injuries and may be linked to cognitive decline. They can also lead to long-term effects, such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and increased suicide rates among veterans.”
I gotta admit, I love this quote from the article: “Researchers are currently exploring how to measure blast exposure and evaluate its effects on soldiers during routine training. As they learn more, the hope is to not only develop diagnostic tests and treatments for those who suffer from the long-term effects of blast waves, but also to find ways to adjust military equipment to decrease the exposure level.” [emphasis mine] I know it’s a simplistic idea, and I’m a simplistic kinda gal, but why not get rid of the damn guns? Issue all GI’s (and cops & robbers) swords and knives. period. Or better yet, get rid of all weapons and use hand to hand martial arts combat only. Yeah! I like that idea the best. Bring Bruce Lee back!
When I was in the Washington State Air National Guard, I fired expert with the M-16 and was asked to join the Rifle Team. It was quite an honor, and I seriously considered it, until I discovered I’d have to buy my own practice ammo. That stuff’s expensive, so I regretfully declined. I don’t know if the competition meets were indoors or outdoors, but being the wimp I am, I imagine most of my target practice would have been indoors. Especially since I lived in the rainy part of the state at the time. Turns out that firing indoors is the worst possible scenario due to a number of factors, primarily the echo effect.
It isn’t the noise, it’s the blast waves. We didn’t evolve surrounded by munitions going off all the time. Our skulls are bone, are permeable to things we can’t see. So, maybe Sheri S. Tepper was truly on to something. Of course, I’m not so naïve as to think we’ll ever get rid of our guns, especially in this country. We don’t care about other people’s lives, why should we care about ours? But boy of boy, it is fun to dream.
Please, if you are a gun enthusiast, and enjoy firing, do it outside where there is a considerable drop in the amount of blast blowback, and stick to smaller weapons. And, yeah, firing is a rush of fun. Take up skeet shooting — 1. it’s an outdoor sport, 2. the longer barrel of the shotgun means less blast effect on your head, and 3. no matter how many skeets you shoot, they will never go on the endangered species list. Honest. Trust me.
In the meantime, give the GIs and the Vets you know and meet, an extra hug. Their sacrifice may be greater than they, or we, know. Especially those who no longer feel safe in a traditional home.
Sorry, I have no photos of projectile weapons, nor of soldiers using same; however, I will share a photo I took a few days ago of some of the local Canada geese preparing to March to Pretoria. Okay, not really. The Boer War ended long before these guys were hatched, but the song is still around. Apparently, the English came up with the song as a rally for the troops marching to Pretoria, and the Boers took it up, and sang it in Afrikaans, so it was a popular song on either side of the war. Who knew? I remember singing it when I was a kidlet but haven’t a clue why. Anyhow my clueless geese, on their way to somewhere in the dawn’s early light…

Yep, there’s one in every crowd…..


